Nitrogen use efficiency in an 11-year study of conventional and organic wheat cultivation

G. L Baeckstrom, U. Hanell and G. Svensson

Abstract
Resource conservation with respect to nitrogen (N) was compared in organic and conventional cultivation of winter and spring wheat. Sustainability was measured in the nitrogen use efficiency of plant-available N. The amounts of N entering each system and the amounts removed in the harvested crop and remaining as unused mineral nitrogen in the soil at harvest were determined. Net surpluses and losses during the growing season were also monitored, and the environmental variables influencing N harvest in the different cultivation systems were identified.

The study was conducted in 3 different cultivation systems, i.e. conventional animal production (CONV), organic animal production (ORG1) and organic cereal production (ORG2).

On average for all years and sampling occasions in winter wheat, there were approximately 60 kg more mineral nitrogen left in the soil during the growing season in CONV than in ORG1, and coefficients of variation were higher in CONV. The maximum values were considerably higher in CONV than in ORG1, which increased the risk of leaching in the former, particularly in winter wheat cultivation.

Nitrogen use efficiency in winter and spring wheat cultivation was 74% in whole crop conventional winter wheat and 81% in organic. Nitrogen use efficiency in harvested winter wheat grain was 44% for CONV and 49% for ORG1. ORG1 spring wheat was as efficient as ORG1 winter wheat, whereas ORG2 spring wheat used 73% of N in the whole crop and 39% in grain.

Multivariate regression analysis showed that climate affected CONV and ORG1 winter wheat differently. High temperature in May increased grain yields in ORG1, but the converse was true for CONV. Large unused mineral N reserves at harvest coincided with large N harvest in CONV winter wheat. Residual fertility effects from the preceding crop produced high yields in ORG1 winter and spring wheat but had no effect in CONV.

Generally, an increase in N reserves between plant development stages 13 and 31 was positive for both CONV and ORG1 winter wheat. Both winter and spring wheat require most N during this period, so the potential for improvement seems to lie in increasing mineralization (e.g. by intensified weed harrowing early in stage 13 in winter wheat and between stages 13 and 31 in spring wheat).

Cultivation of winter wheat in ORG1 was a more efficient use of nitrogen resources than CONV. CONV efficiency could be improved by precision fertilizer application on each individual field with the help of N analysis before spring tillage and sensor-controlled fertilizer application.


Source
Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis (2006) 37: 417-449


Author Locations and Affiliations
Research-Unit, Orebro University Hospital, SE-70185, Orebro, Sweden.
E-mail: gard.baeckstrom@orebroll.se


en français


Posted February 2007